# Discussion on Quranic Interpretations and Hadith

- Original post: https://www.twitter.com/i/status/2119185374409081022
- Source account: [@AbdullahAEsmail](https://x.com/AbdullahAEsmail)
- Source language: Arabic
- Target language: English
- Duration: 1:51
- Published: 2026-11-08
- Machine translated. Check the original before quoting.
- Canonical URL: https://preview.translate.mom/transcript/wSfq6Y9J8FM5/transcript-of-discussion-on-quranic-interpretations-and-hadith

## Transcript

[0:00](https://preview.translate.mom/transcript/wSfq6Y9J8FM5/transcript-of-discussion-on-quranic-interpretations-and-hadith) The Qur’an says that Abu Bakr and Umar drove someone out of a house.

[0:06](https://preview.translate.mom/transcript/wSfq6Y9J8FM5/transcript-of-discussion-on-quranic-interpretations-and-hadith?t=6) And they said that if the Qur’an mentions Abu Jahl and mentions him, people like al- Rabi‘a and people like al- Rabi‘a.

[0:13](https://preview.translate.mom/transcript/wSfq6Y9J8FM5/transcript-of-discussion-on-quranic-interpretations-and-hadith?t=13) And they insulted him, and Abu Bakr, Umar, and Uthman al-Mughira ibn Shu‘ba, and Abu Musa al-Ash‘ari, and Salim, the freedman of Abu Hudhayfa, the hypocrites and the Nasibis.

[0:23](https://preview.translate.mom/transcript/wSfq6Y9J8FM5/transcript-of-discussion-on-quranic-interpretations-and-hadith?t=23) And they are humiliated. They drove her away, leaving nothing but a great commotion.

[0:27](https://preview.translate.mom/transcript/wSfq6Y9J8FM5/transcript-of-discussion-on-quranic-interpretations-and-hadith?t=27) They vilify the Prophet when his uncle… They defended them, all of them, by name.

[0:33](https://preview.translate.mom/transcript/wSfq6Y9J8FM5/transcript-of-discussion-on-quranic-interpretations-and-hadith?t=33) But they are fabricators. And it is not in the Two Sahihs.

[0:36](https://preview.translate.mom/transcript/wSfq6Y9J8FM5/transcript-of-discussion-on-quranic-interpretations-and-hadith?t=36) And in the Musnad of Ahmad ibn Hanbal are many hadiths.

[0:39](https://preview.translate.mom/transcript/wSfq6Y9J8FM5/transcript-of-discussion-on-quranic-interpretations-and-hadith?t=39) Even Umar ibn al- Khattab said, “Two verses from the Book of God…”

[0:44](https://preview.translate.mom/transcript/wSfq6Y9J8FM5/transcript-of-discussion-on-quranic-interpretations-and-hadith?t=44) “Were it not for people saying, ‘Umar added to the Book of God,’ I would have added them.”

[0:49](https://preview.translate.mom/transcript/wSfq6Y9J8FM5/transcript-of-discussion-on-quranic-interpretations-and-hadith?t=49) Ah, from the Book of God People left it. Were it not for people saying, ‘Umar added to the Book of God,’ I would have added them.

[0:56](https://preview.translate.mom/transcript/wSfq6Y9J8FM5/transcript-of-discussion-on-quranic-interpretations-and-hadith?t=56) “The old man and the old woman, if they commit adultery, stone them.”

[0:59](https://preview.translate.mom/transcript/wSfq6Y9J8FM5/transcript-of-discussion-on-quranic-interpretations-and-hadith?t=59) Umar’s hadith exists, and Aisha’s hadith about breastfeeding.

[1:03](https://preview.translate.mom/transcript/wSfq6Y9J8FM5/transcript-of-discussion-on-quranic-interpretations-and-hadith?t=63) He said, “Ten feedings.” She said, “If it is in the Qur’an…”

[1:05](https://preview.translate.mom/transcript/wSfq6Y9J8FM5/transcript-of-discussion-on-quranic-interpretations-and-hadith?t=65) So- and- so, I don’t know who stopped her from completing the recitation.

[1:09](https://preview.translate.mom/transcript/wSfq6Y9J8FM5/transcript-of-discussion-on-quranic-interpretations-and-hadith?t=69) The strange chicken. He narrated it. And Umar, may God be pleased with him.

[1:17](https://preview.translate.mom/transcript/wSfq6Y9J8FM5/transcript-of-discussion-on-quranic-interpretations-and-hadith?t=77) No, no. They drove her away.

[1:25](https://preview.translate.mom/transcript/wSfq6Y9J8FM5/transcript-of-discussion-on-quranic-interpretations-and-hadith?t=85) There is some nuance in Umar’s words. Why does he justify it?

[1:30](https://preview.translate.mom/transcript/wSfq6Y9J8FM5/transcript-of-discussion-on-quranic-interpretations-and-hadith?t=90) The words of al- Hadi, peace be upon him, on rulings.

[1:33](https://preview.translate.mom/transcript/wSfq6Y9J8FM5/transcript-of-discussion-on-quranic-interpretations-and-hadith?t=93) Al-Hadi went on at length about the legitimacy of stoning.

[1:36](https://preview.translate.mom/transcript/wSfq6Y9J8FM5/transcript-of-discussion-on-quranic-interpretations-and-hadith?t=96) This suggests that the tribe practicing stoning was uneasy about it.

[1:39](https://preview.translate.mom/transcript/wSfq6Y9J8FM5/transcript-of-discussion-on-quranic-interpretations-and-hadith?t=99) There were people who opposed stoning. They said, “It isn’t sanctioned. It’s not in the Quran.”

[1:43](https://preview.translate.mom/transcript/wSfq6Y9J8FM5/transcript-of-discussion-on-quranic-interpretations-and-hadith?t=103) So Al- Hadi went on at length about the rulings on the legitimacy of stoning.

[1:46](https://preview.translate.mom/transcript/wSfq6Y9J8FM5/transcript-of-discussion-on-quranic-interpretations-and-hadith?t=106) He looked into it and inferred its legitimacy from the Quran.