Discussion on Language in Religious Texts
1 min Machine translated Faith
Let's say we accept that the language God used was Arabic.
Then why did He give the Torah in Hebrew?
Why did He send Ezekiel in Greek and Aramaic?
Why did God change His mind and His language?
Aren't these valid questions? Then all this is evidence disproving the idea that Adam's and God's language was Arabic.
Above all, Muhammad himself denied in the Quran that it contained foreign words.
But we find foreign words in it. For example, in verse one hundred and three of Surah An- Nahl, it says: “We certainly know that they say a human being is teaching him the Quran.
But the language of the person they mean is foreign.
Whereas this Quran is in clear Arabic.” That's why he denied that foreign words were found in the Quran.
But, as we've seen in previous episodes, there are many foreign words.
Our question still stands. I wonder if any of the esteemed scholars can answer this.
I hope they answer in a way that respects our intelligence.
End of transcript · 172 words · machine translated
Original transcript (Turkish)
Diyelim ki Tanrı'nın kullandığı dilin Arapça olduğunu kabul ettik.
Peki o zaman neden Tevrat'ı İbranice verdi?
Neden Yehezkiel'i Yunanca ve Aramice yolladı?
Neden Tanrı fikrini değiştirdi ve dilini?
Bunlar geçerli sorular değil mi? Öyleyse tüm bunlar Adem'in ve Tanrı'nın dilinin Arapça olduğunu fikirlerini çürüten ispatlardır.
Hepsinden öte, Muhammed'in kendisi Kur'an'da yabancı kelimeler bulunduğunu inkar etmişti.
Ama içinde yabancı kelimeler buluyoruz. Örneğin Nahl suresi yüz üçüncü ayette diyor ki "And olsun ki biz onların Kur'an'ı ona bir insan öğretiyor dediklerini biliyoruz.
Ama ima ettikleri kimsenin dili yabancıdır.
Bu Kur'an ise gayet açık bir Arapçadır."
İşte bu yüzden yabancı kelimelerin Kur'an'da bulunduğunu inkar etti.
Ama daha önceki bölümlerde gördüğümüz üzere birçok yabancı kelime mevcut.
Sorumuz hala duruyor. Saygıdeğer alimler arasında buna cevap verebilecek biri var mı acaba?
Umarım zekamıza saygı göstererek cevap verirler.
Up next
Keep watching Swipe through more videos, one after another
3:12 Understanding the Quran Through Listening 
0:33 Importance of Proper Ritual Cleansing 
4:41 Discussion on Religious Authority and Practices 
9:31 Discussion on Ramayana and Film Adaptations 
2:56 Discussion on Ravana's Character and Origins 
5:00 Analysis of Historical Islamic Events 
6:45 Religious Leader's Call for Prayer and Repentance 
6:08 Analysis of Ibn Taymiyyah's Views on Ali 
9:22 Impact of Shia Beliefs on Historical Narratives 
4:41 Discussion on Shia Beliefs and Practices 
2:56 Mystery of the Shrine Revealed 
2:30 Celebration of Prophet Muhammad's Birth
iPhone app Translate videos on your iPhone Paste a TikTok, Instagram or X link, add subtitles in your language and save the video to Photos. 
Made with TranslateMom
TranslateMom transcribes and translates videos from X, TikTok, YouTube and Instagram. Paste a link and you get a page like this one, in your language.